The best Ender 3 retraction settings

The Creality Ender 3 is probably the most reliable 3D printer under $200, but it can still suffer from issues like oozing and stringing. Adjusting your Ender 3 retraction settings can help solve these problems.

author avatar

07 Sep, 2022

Improve your Ender prints by adjusting retraction settings

Improve your Ender prints by adjusting retraction settings

Thanks to its low price, reliability, and extensive community of users, the Creality Ender 3 has — along with the Ender 3 V2 and Ender 3 Pro — become the go-to FDM printer for beginners since its launch in 2017.

The classic version of the Ender 3 offers features like a 100 °C heated bed, a stick-on magnetic build surface, and precision down to 0.1 mm. Creality has reportedly shipped around 800,000 units of the machine, giving rise to a significant online community of Ender 3 users willing to share their tips and experiences.

Of course, as an entry-level system, the Ender 3 is vulnerable to some of the more common issues associated with FDM 3D printing. Many beginners struggle with the manual bed leveling required by the Ender 3, while the printer can also suffer from bed adhesion issues. 

Two other common issues are the related phenomena of oozing and stringing. Oozing is when excess molten filament leaks or drips from the nozzle, and stringing is when this dripping filament forms weblike patterns over the build during travel movements. While these issues can be partly mitigated by manual post-processing techniques like sanding, most users would prefer to combat the problem at its source, preventing the nozzle from leaking altogether.

One of the best ways to mitigate oozing and stringing is to adjust Ender 3 retraction settings, which is easy to do using a slicer like Cura.[1] This article discusses the various retraction settings available to Ender 3 users, suggesting ideal parameters for the popular Creality 3D printer.

Stringing test prints

Stringing is one of the easiest 3D printing defects to identify. It manifests itself as fine strands of loose filament spread over the surface of the build, particularly over areas where the printhead has made travel movements (movements on the X-Y plane when no filament is being extruded).

If your Ender 3 prints have been plagued by stringing, chances are you’ve already spotted and diagnosed the problem. Nonetheless, it can be useful to perform a controlled stringing test to gauge the extent of the problem and to see if it gets better or worse after adjusting retraction settings.

A good way to measure the severity of stringing is to print a stringing test print. This is a simple 3D model in STL format, usually consisting of two vertical towers. Because the two towers are spaced a short distance apart, the printhead must make travel movements between the towers — movements where it is likely to exhibit stringing.

To make the best use of a stringing test, you should adjust your Ender 3 retraction settings (explained in the following sections) in small intervals, printing a new stringing test model after each adjustment. You can then identify the test print with the least severe stringing, and use the settings that produced that print as your default print settings.

Popular stringing test prints on Thingiverse:

Recommended reading: How to find free STL files

Printing temperature

Adjusting Ender 3 retraction settings is one way to mitigate oozing and stringing. However, before getting into these advanced settings, it is worth attempting a simple temperature adjustment in order to fix the problem.

Oozing is more likely to occur at high extrusion temperatures because hotter temperatures make the filament less viscous (more runny). If the filament is in a highly liquid state, it is more likely to drip out of the nozzle regardless of whether the extruder is applying pressure. Conversely, a lower extrusion temperature keeps the material more viscous and less likely to escape the nozzle.

That being said, a balance must be struck when setting the extrusion temperature. While overly high temperatures can lead to oozing and stringing — as well as over-extrusion issues like blobs and zits — insufficient temperatures can result in other problems like under-extrusion and filament jams.

Most 3D printing filaments have a window of suitable temperatures, with retraction more likely to be necessary at the higher end of that range. The Ender 3 offers a maximum printing temperature of around 240 °C.

Recommended reading: PETG temperature considerations

How retraction settings can fix stringing

When it comes to FDM printing, retraction and stringing are inextricably linked. In fact, one of the main purposes of retraction is to eliminate stringing.

When a 3D printer extrudes material, small gears push the strand of filament toward the hotend. There, the material is melted by the hotend before it passes through the nozzle and onto the build below. But the gears that push filament to the hotend can also reverse direction and pull the filament back away from the hotend. This is called retraction.

Although the already-melted section of filament cannot be retracted, the solid section of filament immediately above the hotend’s melt zone can be. Retracting the solid filament reduces the amount of pressure on the molten material, making it less likely to ooze out of the nozzle and cause stringing.

There are several different retraction settings, all of which can be tweaked to reduce the likelihood of stringing. Generally, however, faster and lengthier retractions are key to mitigating the issue.

stringingUnconfigured retraction settings can lead to stringing

Most important retraction settings

Recommended slicers for the Ender 3 include Cura, Simplify3D, and Slic3r, all of which use slightly different terminology for their retraction settings. This article will discuss the best retraction settings, though some are only available on Cura, which has the greatest number of adjustable parameters. Note that Creality’s own slicer is built on Cura architecture, but most users report better experiences with Cura itself.

Where do I find retraction settings?

  • Cura: Under Material settings in Print Setup

  • Simplify3D: Under Ooze Control settings via the Extruder tab

  • Slic3r: Via the Extruder tab

Enable retraction

Enabling retraction — usually achieved by checking a box, regardless of which slicer you use — tells the 3D printer to perform retractions during travel movements. If this setting is disabled, no retraction will take place during travel movements, making oozing and stringing more likely to occur.

Retraction distance

Retraction distance (retraction length) refers to how much filament the extruder pulls back during the retraction process. It is expressed as a value in millimeters.

In practice, this means that a retraction distance setting of 5 mm will lead to 5 mm of filament being pulled away from the hotend each time a retraction is made. That 5 mm length of filament will then be returned to the hotend once the travel movement is finished.

Severe stringing should be countered with a fairly high retraction distance, sometimes up to 15 mm. Because the Ender 3 uses a Bowden extruder — where the nozzle is some distance away from the extruder gears — rather than a direct-drive extruder, the required retraction distance may be fairly high.

Longer retractions are more likely to prevent stringing than shorter ones, but they also add more time to the print, so a balance must be struck.

Recommended Ender 3 retraction distance: 5 mm, increasing in increments of 1 mm if stringing occurs

Retraction speed

Retraction speed refers to the speed at which the extruder pulls the filament back during the retraction process. It is expressed as a value in millimeters per second.

Faster retraction speeds can help prevent oozing and stringing while also reducing overall print times, but excessive speed can lead to other issues such as filament grinding. As with other FDM printers, the safest Ender 3 retraction speed is in the range of 30–50 mm/s.

Note that some slicers (e.g. Cura) will allow you to set different speeds for retraction (pulling the filament back) and priming (returning the filament to its original position). However, if these fields are left blank, then the overall retraction speed will apply in both situations.

Recommended Ender 3 retraction speed: 50 mm/s, decreasing in increments of 5 mm/s if filament grinding occurs

Maximum retraction count

Maximum retraction count refers to the maximum number of retractions that can be performed on a certain length of filament (see below). It is expressed as a whole number.

When printing a part that requires regular and extensive travel movements, it sometimes happens that the same specific section of filament gets retracted multiple times. For example, if the retraction distance is set at 5 mm, and only 1 mm of filament gets deposited in between two separate travel movements, then 4 mm of filament will have been retracted two times over. This can be a problem, because filament can get worn down if it is pushed and pulled too many times.

If the maximum retraction count is reached for a given length of filament, the printer will cease performing retractions until the length of filament has been deposited onto the build.

Recommended Ender 3 maximum retraction count: 20, decreasing in increments of 5 if filament is suffering from grinding or other damage


Ender 3The Ender 3 should perform about 20 retractions at most on a single length of filament

Minimum extrusion distance window

Minimum extrusion distance window refers to the length of filament that is subject to the maximum retraction count (see above). It is expressed as a value in millimeters.

As an example, if the maximum retraction count is set to 20 and the minimum extrusion distance window to 1 mm, then a given 1 mm length of filament can be retracted a maximum of 20 times before it must be deposited onto the build. To keep things simple, it is recommended to set this value equal to the extrusion distance, using the maximum retraction count as the main variable for altering the frequency of retractions.

Recommended Ender 3 minimum extrusion distance window: 5 mm (or equal to retraction distance)

Extra prime amount

Extra prime amount refers to how much additional filament is primed — pushed back to the hotend following a retraction — on top of the initially retracted length. This additional amount may be necessary in order to compensate for material that has oozed out of the nozzle during the retraction. It is expressed as a value in millimeters.

Materials more prone to oozing such as PETG may require a higher extra prime amount to ensure that the nozzle contains enough filament to prevent under-extrusion. However, this setting can be considered a Plan B, to be used only when the primary retraction settings (see above) are failing to prevent oozing and stringing.

Recommended Ender 3 extra prime amount: 0, unless other retraction settings have failed to prevent oozing

Other retraction settings

A handful of other retraction settings — generally less critical than those mentioned above — may be tweaked within the slicer. These include:

  • Retract at layer change: Refers to whether the printer should perform a retraction when moving from one layer to the next. 

  • Minimum travel: Refers to the smallest distance the printhead must move during a travel movement in order to justify a retraction.

  • Combing: A technique that instructs the printer to make travel movements only within the perimeter of the build, making retractions less important, as any oozed material will fall within the interior of the build.

  • Vertical lift: Called Z-hop in Cura and Z lift in Slic3r, a vertical lift refers to the printhead lifting itself upwards when making a travel movement in order to avoid scraping against the build.

Ender 3 recommended retraction settings

Retraction settings may need to be adjusted depending on the material. A material like PLA is less prone to oozing and stringing than a material like PETG,[2] while a flexible material like TPU is more easily damaged by retractions. These factors will affect the ideal retraction settings. Nonetheless, here are some reliable default settings to use for the Ender 3, suitable for most prints and materials:


Enable retraction

Yes

Retraction distance (length)

5 mm

Retraction speed

50 mm/s

Retract speed

50 mm/s

Prime speed

50 mm/s

Maximum retraction count

20

Minimum extrusion distance window

5 mm

Extra prime amount

0 mm


Key takeaways

The Creality Ender 3 has earned its reputation as a reliable 3D printer with an incredibly low price tag. However, like all FDM 3D printers, it doesn’t always deliver perfect results from the get-go. Users hoping to carry out complex prints with a range of different filament types must learn to master retraction settings in order to avoid oozing and stringing while preventing their material from damage.

The most important things to remember when configuring Ender 3 retraction settings are to use a generous retraction distance to accommodate the Ender’s Bowden extruder, set the maximum retraction count well below the Cura default of 100 unless you’re using indestructible filament, and avoid using an extra prime amount unless you really need to. The resulting prints should — with any luck — be free of excessive stringing, resulting in a high-quality appearance.

References

[1] How to fix stringing [Internet]. Ultimaker Support. [cited 2022 Sep 7]. Available from: https://support.ultimaker.com/hc/en-us/articles/360012016280-How-to-fix-stringing
[2] Holcomb G, Caldona EB, Cheng X, Advincula RC. On the optimized 3D printing and post-processing of PETG materials. MRS Communications. 2022 May 12:1-7.

Tagged with

3d printing

Share

07 Sep, 2022

Educated at King's College London and the University of Amsterdam, Benedict has been a freelance writer in the 3D printing industry since 2015. He is a contributing editor at Aniwaa and a senior writer at 3dpbm.

Wevolver 2022